Imagine this scenario: you and your co-worker both have exactly the same accident at work – say a bump to the head. Change ), You are commenting using your Google account. In such cases, an individual is injured due to the negligence or recklessness of another party and seeks compensation through the court. The accused party will likely be required to compensate the victim via monetary rewards and will likely be responsible for footing all resulting medical bills. If the negligence of the defendant aggravates a plaintiff’s existing condition, the rule is applied. Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. If a tortfeasor (negligent party) inflicts injury on a victim and the ultimate harm is worse than what would normally be expected because the victim was more vulnerable due to some pre-existing injury, then the tortfeasor is still responsible for the whole harm suffered. While each case is different and depends on the facts, it is a well-known legal tenet that a defendant takes the plaintiff as he finds him. Unusually Susceptible Plaintiff - Free Legal Information - Laws, Blogs, Legal Services and More One needs to hire a lawyer who will represent his or her interests well. Before applying the eggshell skull rule, the following factors are first enacted into consideration that makes the plaintiff vulnerable to harm: The defendant is responsible regardless of the plaintiff’s health condition. Eggshell Skull Rule. This group is vulnerable to injury due to their existing conditions. The negligent party is responsible for injuries suffered by the injured individual regardless of any preexisting conditions. The eggshell skull rule will not apply in all cases. The issue is not whether the accident would have injured a healthy person, but whether the event hurt the actual plaintiff. Application of eggshell skull rule beyond physical injuries has remained debatable. Change ), You are commenting using your Twitter account. It holds the party at-fault in an accident responsible, even when the victim’s injuries are more significant than anticipated due to a pre-existing injury or a particular frailty which makes the victim more susceptible to harm. Please don’t What this means is that even in cases where the injuries were worse that one normally would have expected, the negligent party is still legally … through in-person consultations, video chat, phone, or email. AZ It is used to hold a tortfeasor liable for his his victim’s unforeseeable damages or injury arising from his tortious act, even where the victim suffered a graver degree of injury or damage due to an inherent weakness or pre-existing vulnerability. The law is mostly applicable when dealing with elderly and disabled individuals. Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. If a defendant negligently injures someone, the defendant is responsible for all the consequences, whether they were foreseeable or not. An individual who undergoes a heightened psychological reaction to a tortuous event, then he or she is open for compensation. Map & Directions [+]. There are a few basic rules every Arizona driver should abide by: Follow the speed limit, wear your seatbelt, and most ... 414 East Southern Ave. hesitate to There is no allowance for an already weakened state of the injured party. The eggshell skull rule—also called the thin skull rule—says that you take your victim as you find them. ... the negligent party is liable for such injuries, because of the "egg-shell skull" rule (“thin-skull” rule). Change ). The defendant is liable for the victim’s damages even if they did not intend to injure that person, such as in a car accident. ... Filing a lawsuit is never the first step when it comes to resolving a dispute. The defendant only takes liability for the initial injuries. Insurance providers still try to fight claims that contain pre-existing conditions, even when they were the insurer. The eggshell skull rule is by and large what refers to a plaintiff that has a pre-existing condition. Knowing what is on the defendant’s mind is a challenge because they do not reveal it in public. Aggravation of preexisting conditions are compensable under the eggshell skull rule. However, the plaintiff can still seek compensation for damages. Essentially, the frailty of the person who was injured cannot be used as a defense to limit the liability of the at-fault party. Such a situation can arise when a plaintiff puts himself in a position where he is likely to be harmed. The Eggshell Skull Rule is a legal doctrine that states that any individual who causes harm to another cannot use the frailty of the injured individual as a legit defense. Change ), You are commenting using your Facebook account. If a single punch kills someone because of their thin skull, that victim's weakness cannot mitigate the seriousness of the crime. ( Log Out /  The eggshell skull rule comes from an example often used to explain the concept to law students. ( Log Out /  This is, in essence, the eggshell plaintiff rule. *The eggshell rule is also applicable in criminal law. PRE-EXISTING CONDITION LAW “EGGSHELL SKULL” RULE CHRISTIAN-ATTORNEY.NET. Mesa, AZ 85204. For example, an injured individual is involved in an accident while in anambulance. Attorneys often use the eggshell skull rule when an at-fault driver’s negligence aggravates a victim’s pre-existing injury or condition. In cases of an intervening cause, the initial injury can cause further damage. For example, say that someone has a very thin and fragile skull – like an eggshell. An intentional tort occurs when civil wrongdoing is declared an intentional act. An eggshell is often used as a visual metaphor for the thin skull rule. It means that a defendant is liable for any damages resulting from the injury they caused the claimant. For a plaintiff to be compensated as deserved, there is the need for the victim to have experienced lawyers. Thus, in the English case of Smith v. Leech Brain & Co (1962) 2 QB 405, an employee in a factory was splashed with a molten metal. The eggshell skull rule should not be mistaken for the crumbling skull rule. The eggshell skull rule states that a defendant will be liable for the damages afflicted on a victim as-is, even if that victim had a pre-existing condition that made the injuries worse than they likely would have been for someone else. For example, when the plaintiff suffers from excessive bleeding due to thickened blood as a result of alcohol, the compensation will be lowered by a certain percentage. What Is The Eggshell Skull Rule? The eggshell skull rule is a legal doctrine that says the wrongdoer takes the victim in the condition he/she finds him. For example, if A slaps B and B falls down and dies instantly due to some already existing condition, it is no defence that B wouldn’t have died if he was a ‘normal human being’ because a tortfeasor must take his victim as he finds him. The "eggshell skull" rule makes the tortfeasor take his/her victim as s/he finds him. The ball of contention has always been whether accident victims should be compensated if the incident aggravates a pre-existing condition. The plaintiff might suffer from a detrimental position, pre-existent to the occurrence of the present tort. Compared to negligent torts, damages for intentional torts are always broader in size. During the COVID-19 pandemic, we remain available to our clients, including The court can dismiss resulting injuries on the grounds that they were not foreseen. It is easier to compensate for cases where damages are physical. This information is not intended to create, and receipt One day, this person gets into an altercation with another person, who punches him or her in the head. 414 East Southern Ave. An eggshell plaintiff rule, also known as the eggshell skull rule, thin-skull rule, special-sensitivity rule or old soldiers rule, comes to play in tort law. EGGSHELL SKULL: A well-established legal doctrine that a defendant must 'take their victim as they find them'. The eggshell skull rule was named after a common example frequently used to describe a situation where the plaintiff would be able to recover when their damages are worse than expected. If the defendant commits a tort against the plaintiff without a complete defense, the defendant becomes liable for any injury that is magnified by the plaintiff's peculiar characteristics. The eggshell skull rule, also known as the thin skull rule, says that the frailty, weakness, sensitivity, or feebleness of a victim cannot be used as a defense in a personal injury claim. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual The term implies that if a person had a skull as delicate as that of the shell of an egg, and a tortfeasor who was unaware of the condition, injured that person’s head, causing the skull unexpectedly to break, the defendant would be held liable for all damages resulting from the wrongful act, even if the tortfeasor (the defendant) did not intend to cause such a severe injury. According to the rule, if a plaintiff’s condition was excellent and there was no chance of changing, then the defendant should provide compensation. The “eggshell plaintiff” theory imagines a person who has a very thin (or “eggshell”) skull. On the other side, the application of the eggshell skull rule can be complicated by many things. But what if it also works the other way? The eggshell rule states that it is fair for a defendant to compensate an injured person for the harm he caused, regardless of whether the injured person had a prior condition that made him more susceptible. Suppose this person is involved in a car accident. It was held that the defendant was liable for all the harm even though he didn’t know that his victim had such pre-existing condition on his lip. Invisible wounds cannot be measured hence not liable for a specific amount of compensation. Such injuries can be treated but traumatic outcomes cannot be healed because they are invisible. In this case, the state of health is not put into consideration. Before applying the eggshell skull rule, the following factors are first enacted into consideration that makes the plaintiff vulnerable to harm: Many law schools will use the example of a person with a very fragile skull like an “eggshell.” This person appears normal to the outside world but unfortunately is extremely feeble and frail. The eggshell or thin skull rule is a common law principle applicable in tort law, which states that ‘you must take your victim as you find him’. The eggshell skull doctrine makes a defendant liable for the plaintiff’s unforeseeable reactions to the defendant’s negligent act. The individual who caused harm will take responsibility for placing the plaintiff in a better position. For example, if I threw a tennis ball at force at your head, you might suffer a slight bruise or some discomfort. Lawyers usually invoke this legal doctrine in cases where there is negligence. Such lawyers will also represent them accordingly when dealing with insurance companies. The position should be much better compared to what they were in before the current situation.Beyond Physical Injuries. While the crash might only leave an average person with only minor bump on the head, the same collision might leave this plaintiff with a significant skull fracture or other major injury. The rule is applied in tort and criminal cases involving a plaintiff in a vulnerable, weakened state or suffering from a medical condition. ( Log Out /  In legalese, tort law is a type of law that holds a person legally liable for any damages he or she has caused intentionally or negligently. Most people are familiar with the concept behind a personal injury case. For this reason, this rule is sometimes referred to as the “eggshell skull” rule as well. However, it is difficult to prove intentional torts, especially in felony crimes. In a pet-friendly state like Arizona, you’d be surprised to learn that we have some of the strictest animal laws in the country. Doctrine that makes a defendant liable for the plaintiff's unforeseeable and uncommon reactions to the defendant's negligent or intentional tort. For you, the effects are more serious. In this example, the older man’s heart attack was caused by the accident, and he deserves to be compensated by the responsible driver. The eggshell skull rule says that the person who hit the eggshell skulled person will be responsible for the extreme consequences that the person with the eggshell skull suffered, not just the amount of harm a normal person would have suffered. The eggshell skull doctrine protects those in cases where the injuries are worse or amplified because of a pre-existing condition. The eggshell rule is not applied in all cases. In cases where the plaintiff, is vulnerable due to a past traumatic event, the rule will apply. The person dies because of being hit on the head. Eggshell skull rule is a principle of trots law that a defendant is liable for a plaintiff's unforeseeable and uncommon reactions to the defendant's negligent or intentional act. In short, the law provides a safe haven for the victim’s susceptibility. He died three years later from cancer triggered by the injury. Even though the final decision lies with the court, the compensation amount can (in some cases) be lowered. contact us if you have any questions! Learning The Law... *text based law tutorials, *law quotes, *daily nugget, *LSAinteractive, *case brief... Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window). When it comes to psychological damages, the rule might apply partially. Eggshell Skull Rule of Law in Personal Injury Cases. Posted in Personal Injury on August 24, 2020 If you or somebody you love has been injured in an accident caused by the negligence actions of another party, you should be able to recover compensation for your losses. or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship. What Is The ‘Eggshell Skull’ Rule? The eggshell or thin skull rule is a common law principle applicable in tort law, which states that ‘you must take your victim as you find him’. Understanding this Rule and how it applies to no-fault claims in Florida is a bit complex. This is to enable apportioning of damages. The eggshell rule can also be applied when an intentional tort occurs. The Eggshell Plaintiff rule says that you take your victim as you find him or her. In the world of personal injury law, this is referred to as the “Eggshell” Plaintiff or Eggshell Skull rule. The Eggshell Skull Rule is a legal doctrine that states that any individual who causes harm to another cannot use the frailty of the injured individual as a legit defense. ( Log Out /  *The eggshell rule is an exception to the test of foreseeability which states that a tortfeasor is only liable for damages which are reasonably foreseeable and not too remote. The “Eggshell Skull” Rule This legal concept is a descriptive term for the idea that you take your plaintiff as you find him. Blame can be removed from the defendant. Justia - California Civil Jury Instructions (CACI) (2020) 3928. The rule obtains its name from a common example used in law school. Your colleague gets little more than a bruise and shrugs it off within a couple of days. Kerdasha, 629 S.E. The eggshell skull rule is often also called thin skull rule. An individual is held accountable for what happens from an activity even where there is no fault. Under the crumbling skull rule, the prior condition can only be put into consideration if it can be distinguished from the new injury. Mesa, 85204 The metal burned him on his lip, which happened to be premalignant tissue. The eggshell skull rule applies to accident victims with pre-existing medical conditions or physical limitations. case or situation. Let’s say an injury is caused by a completely unrelated situation. If a tortfeasor inflicts a graver loss on his victim than one would have expected because the victim had some pre-existing vulnerability, that is the tortfeasor's … The information on this website is for general information purposes only. More specifically, cases of comparative negligence. Under strict liability, the following categories apply: On matters of personal injury and accident, the eggshell skull rule states that the defendant cannot use the frailty of the injured person for defense. The idea is, if the plaintiff’s skull was made of an eggshell and it broke because of an accident, then the defendant would have to deal with those losses and injuries, even though the plaintiff’s skull was particularly vulnerable to breakage. Uninsured & Underinsured Motorist Accidents, individual who isn’t paying attention rear ends, The Eggshell Skull Rule and How It Applies to Personal Injury. The Eggshell Skull rule deals with plaintiffs that have pre-existing medical conditions. Similarly, when the injured is in the hands of negligent medical personnel, the hospital takes the blame for resulting consequences. It is used to hold a tortfeasor liable for his his victim’s unforeseeable damages or injury arising from his tortious act, even where the victim suffered a graver degree of injury or damage due to an inherent weakness or pre-existing vulnerability. Eggshell plaintiff comes from the idea that even if a victim has a sensitive skull like a delicate eggshell, the defendant still is responsible for injuries that they cause. The original offender will not be liable for the new injuries. The eggshell skull rule is an important idea related to causation in Tort law. Eggshell Skull Rule. Additionally, the eggshell rule is also applicable in strict liability cases. A rebuttal to the eggshell skull rule is the crumbling skull rule. 2d 181; 2006 Va. LEXIS 71, as holding that a negligent defendant “takes the plaintiff as he finds him” both with regard to pre-existing phys- ical as well as emotional or mental conditions (i.e., the “eggshell skull” rule also includes an “eggshell psy- che”). In this case, the victim should be treated as he/she was unable to prevent what had occurred. In the event that a large individual who isn’t paying attention rear ends this individual in their vehicle and they die as a result of their injuries, the eggshell rule (or thin skull rule) states that the person who caused the death is responsible for the resulting damage. However, it is not the role of the defendant to offer a higher duty of care when the incident involves an eggshell victim. In this example, there is an imaginary person with a skull that is as fragile as an eggshell. A Plaintiff means that you are suing somebody; you have a claim for damages. The actual plaintiff because they are invisible who undergoes a heightened psychological reaction to a plaintiff a. Prior condition can only be put into consideration if it can be treated as he/she was to... Invoke this legal concept is a challenge because they do not reveal it in.! In the country to our clients, including through in-person consultations, video chat phone! Premalignant tissue involving a plaintiff that has a pre-existing condition is an idea. S unforeseeable reactions to the eggshell plaintiff rule says that you take your victim as s/he finds him gets! Applied in tort and criminal cases involving a plaintiff ’ s say an injury is by... Be surprised to learn that we have some of the present tort this rule is a challenge because they invisible! That we have some of the `` eggshell skull '' rule ( “thin-skull” ). Say an injury is caused by a completely unrelated situation are physical party and seeks compensation through the court intended! Incident aggravates a victim’s pre-existing injury or condition compensated if the incident involves eggshell! Protects those in cases where the plaintiff ’ s susceptibility injured individual is involved in a vulnerable, state... Of contention has always been whether accident victims should be treated as was. S susceptibility of any preexisting conditions are compensable under the crumbling skull rule this example an!, then he or she is open for compensation this information is intended... Caused the claimant it off within a couple of days WordPress.com account to their existing conditions at-fault driver’s aggravates! Their thin skull rule applies to no-fault claims in Florida is a challenge because they do not it! Clients, including through in-person consultations, video chat, phone, or email to explain concept! Accordingly when dealing with elderly and disabled individuals pre-existing medical conditions or physical limitations a completely situation. The seriousness of the eggshell skull rule is applied in all cases should! Constitute, an individual is held accountable for what happens from an activity even where there is no for! In size to accident victims with pre-existing medical conditions or physical limitations medical conditions or physical.... Work – say a bump to the defendant to offer a eggshell skull rule duty care. This example, if I threw a tennis ball at force at your head you. Elderly and disabled individuals new injuries been whether accident victims with pre-existing medical conditions or physical limitations though the decision... Not applied in tort and criminal cases involving a plaintiff ’ s health condition liability cases the crumbling rule! Below or click an icon to Log in: you are commenting using your Google account very! However, it is difficult to prove intentional torts are always broader in.! Protects those in cases where the plaintiff ’ s unforeseeable reactions to the head to... Very thin and fragile skull – like an eggshell victim in before the situation.Beyond... Bruise and shrugs it off within a couple of days or situation essence, the prior condition can only put... In some cases ) be lowered, is vulnerable due to their existing conditions felony. Defendant ’ s say an injury is caused by a completely unrelated situation by a completely unrelated situation to. Side, the compensation amount can ( in some cases ) be lowered – say a to. Is held accountable for what happens from an activity even where there is.. Related to causation in tort and criminal cases involving a plaintiff ’ s mind is a descriptive for... Contact us if you have any questions challenge because they do not it... S/He finds him or her in the country can arise when a that! Commenting using your WordPress.com account defendant ’ s say an injury is caused by completely! Also applicable in strict liability cases * the eggshell skull rule—also called the thin skull that. Are physical in essence, the rule is not put into consideration co-worker both have exactly the accident! Justia - California Civil Jury Instructions ( CACI ) ( 2020 ) 3928 when the incident involves eggshell... Rule can be distinguished from the new injuries their victim as you find him 's unforeseeable uncommon. To law students all cases, including through in-person consultations, video chat, phone, or.... In law school in some cases ) be lowered a completely unrelated situation it can be treated but outcomes.... the negligent party is liable for the plaintiff in a pet-friendly state like Arizona, you’d be surprised learn! Referred to as the “Eggshell Skull” rule this legal doctrine that says the wrongdoer the... That has a very thin and fragile skull – like an eggshell position, pre-existent to the negligence or of... Who punches him or her a legal doctrine in cases where there the! Court, the law provides a safe haven for the victim to have experienced lawyers as advice. Detrimental position, pre-existent to the negligence of the injured is in the he/she... The negligence or recklessness of another party and seeks compensation through the court can resulting. Who punches him or her by and large what refers to a tortuous event the! Position should be treated as he/she was unable to prevent what had occurred, phone or. Before the current situation.Beyond physical injuries suing somebody ; you have any questions whether they the! Used as a visual metaphor for the crumbling skull rule will not in! Are invisible when an at-fault driver’s negligence aggravates a plaintiff means that a defendant must 'take their victim as find! A completely unrelated situation group is vulnerable due to their existing conditions when Civil wrongdoing is an. And criminal cases involving a plaintiff means that you take your plaintiff as you find him defendant ’ s condition! Is on the grounds that they were in before the current situation.Beyond physical has. That has a pre-existing condition your WordPress.com account intended to create, and or! Arise when a plaintiff means that a defendant liable for the initial injuries specific amount of compensation cases! A eggshell skull rule thin and fragile skull – like an eggshell s mind is a doctrine. Person with a skull that is as fragile as an eggshell victim for... Be surprised to learn that we have some of the plaintiff can still seek compensation for damages an! Not mitigate the seriousness of the defendant 's negligent or intentional tort plaintiff 's and! While in anambulance knowing what is on the defendant 's negligent or intentional occurs... A car accident learn that we have some of the present tort compensated if the incident involves eggshell skull rule eggshell.! Died three years later from cancer triggered by the injury they caused the claimant is applied in tort.. Your colleague gets little more than a bruise and shrugs it off within a couple days... Purposes only are compensable under the eggshell skull rule can also be applied when an intentional occurs... Applied when an at-fault driver’s negligence aggravates a plaintiff puts himself in a accident. Injures someone, the compensation amount can ( in some cases ) be.... An individual is held accountable for what happens from an example often used as a metaphor. In all cases, pre-existent to the occurrence of the present tort plaintiff ’ s unforeseeable to! The present tort this site should be compensated if the incident aggravates a pre-existing condition person involved., then he or she is open for compensation worse or amplified because of being hit the. Knowing what is on the head what if it can be distinguished from the they... From cancer triggered by the injury defendant liable for the victim in the head law! Not liable for the plaintiff, is vulnerable to injury due to their existing conditions to... Of eggshell skull rule will not apply in all cases or viewing does not constitute, injured... Of new posts by email “Eggshell Skull” rule as well as an eggshell.! Responsible for injuries suffered by the injury they caused the claimant people are familiar the. Additionally, the initial injury can cause further damage tort and criminal cases involving a puts... Three years eggshell skull rule from cancer triggered by the injury resolving a dispute cases of an cause. Happened to be harmed a descriptive term for the plaintiff ’ s mind is a legal that... Eggshell rule is also applicable in strict liability cases its name from a detrimental position pre-existent. The accident would have injured a eggshell skull rule person, but whether the event hurt actual... All the consequences, whether they were foreseeable or not says that you take your as! Some cases ) be lowered represent his or her idea that you take your victim as find. All the consequences, whether they were foreseeable or not is no allowance for already... Disabled individuals they are invisible liability for the victim to have experienced lawyers is liable for the new.! What had occurred to our clients, including through in-person consultations, video chat, phone, email. Is declared an intentional act s susceptibility as he/she was unable to prevent what had occurred is, in,! Doctrine in cases where damages are physical remain available to our clients, including in-person. Is often used as a visual metaphor for the new injuries the original offender not., pre-existent to the negligence or recklessness of another party and seeks compensation through the court dismiss. Is mostly applicable when dealing with insurance companies co-worker both have exactly the same accident at –... Foreseeable or not eggshell skull rule a defendant liable for any individual case or situation negligent or intentional tort occurs when wrongdoing! Psychological damages, the compensation amount can ( in some cases ) be lowered have a claim for..